AWARE
Straits Times exposed!
Over-covering a scandal while playing down bigger national issues like suffering citizens and huge investment losses shows up its provincialism. Commentary. Yeo Toon Joo.
May 2, 2009

The ex-news editor of the Straits Times (now retired), Yeo Toon Joo, 61, has offered this article for our publication on what he thinks is the deteriorating journalism in his former newspaper). The following is what he wrote:

The inordinately extensive and daily coverage of the AWARE leadership tussle exposes and underscores the provincialism of Singapore’s press, the Straits Times in particular.

Any thinking person, with a modicum of appreciation of what constitutes news, must marvel over the MSM’s (mainstream media) ability to ignore the real issues of the day in Singapore while focusing so much of its might on what was primarily a parochial affair.

Instead of enlightening Singaporeans on the pressing issues confronting us – events that beg many questions and offer much scope for enquiry – our national press chooses to rivet readers’ attention through a daily barrage of reporting on the dispute of a marginal organization, till recently, of no more than 100 or 200 feminists.

Has the subservient MSM lost its way, just as AWARE allegedly had lost its own focus and objective?

It is incredible that the full strength of the MSM’s reporting staff had failed so remarkably to ferret out the real issue of the leadership coup – until spoon-fed by the protagonist.

In the not too distant days of yore, one of my rookie reporters would surely have enlightened us, and quite early on, too.

The Straits Times’s willingness to manipulate, or be manipulated (wittingly so) by minority interest groups, is so clear for all to see: any image consultant worth his salt will promptly point out how the ST’s photo/news editor had deliberately selected for publication the most frumpy photos of the new committee while editing so dramatically the most flattering portraits of the old, ousted committee members.

Sure, concern over AWARE’s alleged espousal of the cause of lesbianism and homosexuality was at the crux of the crisis. But this is no longer the hot issue of the day.

Aren’t there other pressing national issues worth examining? Is Singapore so boring that a storm in a teacup should excite the brains of its handpicked leaders?

Should the people who wield the mighty pen (in our newspaper offices) engage in such peevishness? And be so actively stoking it up into a national controversy?

If our national press is truly unable to focus on what concern more Singaporeans than what used to engage a handful of AWARE feminists, may I suggest that it thinks about real national issues and cease its tomfoolery.

May I offer some news gathering tips to our wayward press:

** Stop conducting yourself like a mosquito press while holding – by default only – the mantle of a national daily

** Be serious and desist from propagating a modern version of yellow culture in your pages or so-called Life-style sections (“Bollywood’s newest hotties”! My foot! Only good upbringing constrain me from a rude retort; MITA whither art thou?)

** Stop flaunting semi-nude bodies in your life-style pages or flashing regularly the bust lines of dumb broads, and exalting the careers of those engaged in promoting the bacchanalian life styles of geeks and Zouks

** Desist from playing up the prating of some misguided, immature, amorous young reporter who boasts about squeezing some exposed part of a film or rock star (such a confession should, in a court of law, rightly result in a charge of criminal molestation)

** Tell us about the vast disparity of incomes in our so-called 1st World economic miracle and how suffering Singaporeans are coping with the recession

** Instead of giving him scant attention, tell us more and truthfully about Kenneth Jeyaretnam, JBJ’s second son and his dream for the Reform Party. What about his brother Philip?

** Tell us also about the millions being frittered away everyday to finance the myriad failed bio-tech start-ups, and round it up with a balance sheet of Singapore’s successes-failures in this field – and what prospect the future holds

** Tell us something about how our Ah Bengs and Ah Lians are coping in this new world order and with unemployment, or do they not exist?

** Explain how that Singapore family could lose its 5-room HDB flat, and fall through the cracks of MCDYS’s social benefits safety net to spend the past year cadging for food and sleeping on park benches

** If the Straits Times press could devote a full page to profiling China’s five rising stars, why do our leaders in Temasek remain anonymous? Can’t get an interview with them? Surely!

** How will Singapore hope to recover some of its lost national wealth in the world’s economic downturn?

** If even a Warren Buffett could be caught out by the economic downturn and make some massive investment mistakes why is blogosphere so unkind to and unreasonable with Ho Ching?

** If Singapore could throw up a Ho Ching, a truly remarkable woman, why are so few women in parliament and just one has become a full fledge cabinet minister? (This is one issue the old AWARE could have shown some gumption in pursuing)

** Tell us how are our million guest workers, especially the lower-skilled ones, coping with Singapore’s recession and what is their likely fate; this study could also include the sub-standard living conditions of these people, the prostitute camps that used to spring up overnight around their dormitories, and their exploitation by hard-pressed and ruthless employers

** We read that, together with the 1.8k workers whose contracts were terminated prematurely, total redundancy in Singapore increased to a record 12.6k in 1Q09. Obviously, poor people do not exist in the MSM’s world; everyone seems to be happily employed only in media and marketing, if not in the press

** Tells us also what it means to our society to have a trade volume that is three times our GDP; does this not affect our values?

** Throw the spotlight on our local banks, e.g. how did the still independent OCBC and UOB manage to escape being caught more deeply in CDOs and toxic assets of other banks?

** How is Wee Cho Yaw planning his leadership renewal and how he built up his father’s little bank into the behemoth it is today without a foreigner at the helm, while OCBC still struggles to raise its profile, and why DBS with all its patronage is not faring so well

** Stop publishing all the incredible ‘feel good’ stories that we read daily, e.g. how our displaced unemployed workers are merrily engaging in community work, how Mr Mohd Zainuddin is happily adapting to a lowly paid job (1/3 what he used to earn) and is so optimistically looking forward to promotion in his new found position, and signing for self-improvement marketing courses in his late middle-age

** And, if you are truly interested in why and how people become homosexual, conduct a real examination of this subject. Give us, in a non-partisan and objective manner, an intelligent digest of the question. So many people, including even senior cabinet ministers, still labour under much misunderstanding of this subject. Apparently, too, even our Minister Iswaran (Education) and the Ministry’s director of education programmes have not read the old AWARE’s manual on sex education before issuing a defence on the issue a few days ago.

The ideas thrown up above are quick from-the-hip suggestions that any news editor worth three-quarters his salt would suggest on a daily basis, even hourly if need be.

That’s because, unlike now, the journalists of old used to be trained, sensitive, experienced and fiercely jealous of their independence. We were not automatons who had to wait for cues from news editors who reside outside the newsroom.

I know Saturday’s EGM at AWARE will throw up more morsels for the MSM to continue its feeding frenzy. If it is true that the newspapers of a country reflect the caliber and depth of a society’s intellect, then the MSM does Singaporeans much injustice.

Comments
Excerpts of readers’ comments in Wayang Party.com

Peter
What rubbish. The AWARE saga is newsworthy. It has drama, colourful personalities and an interesting underlying subtext (the religion issue).
You mean you’d rather read about people losing their jobs? What sort of media do you want? CCTV, TASS? Perhaps we should fill the pages of ST with 10-year economic plans and pictures of tough looking women toiling in the fields.
The stories you suggest are boring. Who cares about the succession plan of UOB.
Frankly, if Singapore is such a terrible place to live, why not emigrate. I suggest Mexico.

Anonymous
Some substance finally. Bravo! Bravo!

Wolverine
Finally a well-balanced article published by WP. After reading so many lob-sided articles by WP, i have thought WP has lost it’s way. I hope WP can continue to be an viable alternative main source of balance reports that the people duely lack here.

gambit
the media has always strove to make cents sense of any controversy. who wants to read about civil resolution when a cat fight is always so much more intriguing?

bah
Drama happens at AWARE. People are interested. ST runs several articles on it. Wayang Party runs several articles on it.
BUT DO NOT BE FOOLED! The ST reported it to increase the support to the gahmen, and was manipulated by various shady groups into brainwashing the public! Everything they publish is propaganda anyway, so even though WP and ST essentially reported the same event, ST did it for nefarious purposes. Remember people, WP good, ST bad.
Anyone who does not agree with me has already been brainwashed by reading too much articles about AWARE on the ST, and must be re-educated.

cram
Amusing to see Wayangparty also devoting so much space to the AWARE affair. How better are you guys from MSM?

Andrew Chan
Musings from YASRP? (Yet-Another-Self-Righteous-Prick)

Nobody
If we replace TSM with a dishonest leader, and replace Josie and her new exco with an inept team, we will see that WPC is improving on their whistleblowing technique and their ways of exposing the truth behind the propagandized slant used by an incumbent. I say give the team a Tiger.

Beware
After reading the reports in msm, I can’t help but form the conclusion that it was the ST journalists who were using religions to further their agenda. They were the ones who made a lot of speculations even before the new exco have started work. ISD should investigate the background these ST journalists. Who are behind them? Why have they exploited the AWARE leadership change to cause so much disquiet in the past one month?

http://wayangparty.com/?p=8714